Supreme Court of Louisiana January 20, 1975, 54887 (Turner v. Bucher)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-01-1975
308 So.2d 270 (1975) Laura Wallace, wife of August TURNER, and August Turner v. Francis BUCHER and Zurich Insurance Company. No. 54887. Supreme Court of Louisiana. January 20, 1975. Rehearing Denied February 24, 1975. *271 Lawrence D. Wiedemann, Wiedemann & Fransen, New Orleans, for plaintiffs-applicants. Wood Brown, III, Montgomery, Barnett, Brown & Read, New Orleans, for defendant-respondent. BARHAM, Justice. The precise question presented for our determination in this suit is whether the father of a six-year-old child is liable for damages which arose when the child struck one of the plaintiffs with his bicycle on a city sidewalk. The activity causing plaintiff's injury would have been sufficiently negligent, imprudent and careless to constitute civil negligence if the child had been a person of discernment. The court of appeal denied recovery. 293 So.2d 535 (La. App. 4th Cir. 1974). We granted certiorari to review that judgment. 295 So.2d 808 (La.1974). We reverse the judgment of the court of appeal. Laura Wallace Turner, a sixty-two-year-old woman, was walking on a sidewalk in the city of New Orleans when she was struck from the rear and injured by a bicycle ridden by six-year-old Gregory Bucher. In their trial court petition, the plaintiffs alleged the child's independent negligence. It is not disputed that if gauged by the usual standards of conduct, the actions of Gregory Bucher would have constituted negligence on his part. However, plaintiffs conceded that under the jurisprudence, a six-year-old child could not be capable of fault or negligence. On appeal, plaintiffs urged only the personal negligence of the parents in their supervison of the child as the basis of liability of the father for the injury caused by the child. Before this Court, the plaintiffs have broadened their theory for recovery in writ application, in brief, and in argument; and we must properly resolve the case before us under the applicable law. See La.C.C.P. art. 2164.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit