Court of Special Appeals of Maryland May 6, 1975, 813, September Term, 1974 (Byrum v. Maryott)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1975
combined-opinion
26 Md. App. 130 (1975) 337 A.2d 142 ELIZABETH Y. BYRUM ET VIR v. CARLTON MARYOTT ET AL. No. 813, September Term, 1974. Court of Special Appeals of Maryland. Decided May 6, 1975. *131 John C. Lowe with whom was Robert Anthony Jacques on the brief, for appellants. Michael J. Budow with whom were Joseph Patrick Clancy and Clancy & Pfeifer on the brief, for appellees. THOMPSON, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. SMITH, J., dissents and filed a dissenting opinion at page 139 infra. Elizabeth and Barney Byrum, appellants, sued Carlton and Arthur Maryott in the Circuit Court for Montgomery County for damages to Mrs. Byrum and their marital relationship resulting from an automobile accident which occurred in Montgomery County on December 12, 1969. Directed verdicts as to the issue of negligence were granted in favor of the appellants as to Carlton Maryott, the appellee, and in favor of Arthur Maryott. The case went to the jury on the question of damages. The jury returned a verdict of $5000 for Mrs. Byrum's injuries and $2000 for the damage to and interruption of appellants' marital relationship. After all of the appellants' evidence had been received the appellants attempted to introduce mortality tables into evidence to show Mrs. Byrum's life expectancy. The trial court, after intimating that there was evidence of permanency and after stating that the question was for the jury, sustained the appellees' objection, apparently on the theory that more evidence of permanency was required to lay a foundation for the introduction of mortality tables than to raise a jury question as to permanency.[1] The appellants claim the court erred in excluding the mortality tables. We agree and reverse the judgment. Courts in Maryland have long recognized the propriety of *132 using mortality or life expectancy tables to give some guidance to the jury in personal injury or wrongful death cases. In B. & O.R.R. Co. v. Whitacre, 124 Md. 411, 92 A. 1060 (1915), aff'd.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit