Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court January 10, 1975 (Commonwealth v. THE STUYVESANT INSURANCE CO.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-01-1975

Tauro, C.J.

These are seven actions brought by the Commonwealth against the defendant surety on defaulted

*612

bail bonds. At trial without a jury in the Superior Court, the judge found for the plaintiff in the full face amount of the bonds, $7,000. The case is before us on the defendant’s consolidated bill of exceptions which challenges the judge’s failure to grant the defendant’s motion for exoneration and discharge and the judge’s denial of five of the defendant’s requests for rulings of law.

1

In essence, the defendant (surety) claims that the evidence warranted rulings that the bonds were void at the time the default was entered and that the surety had surrendered its principal in exoneration and discharge of its obligations before default. We hold that the bonds were void and sustain the exceptions.

The following facts appear from the statement of agreed facts included in the bill of exceptions. William Hoar, Jr.

*613

(the principal) was named in seven separate District Court complaints. He gave bail to appear and answer each of the complaints or subsequent indictments returned against him. The surety, acting throtigh its attorney-in-fact, executed surety bonds on the principal’s behalf for all seven complaints. After the principal had been bound over to the Superior Court, the grand jury returned seven indictments against him. He appeared for arraignment in the Superior Court and pleaded not guilty. When the case was called for trial on January 14, 1970, however, the principal failed to appear. Both he and the surety were defaulted and a copias was issued for the principal’s arrest.

The police apprehended the principal and arrested him on the copias. On March 2, 1970, the principal was taken before a judge of the Superior Court. The judge removed the default against the principal and the surety and ordered the principal held without bail pending the appearance of an agent for the surety.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.