Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York October 23, 1975 (Barnosky v. Petteys)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-10-1975

Koreman, J.

The contract in question was for the purchase *135of real property consisting of 135 acres, more or less, by the plaintiffs from the defendants, for the agreed price of $35,000. The trial court found that the sales agreement was prepared under the direction of the plaintiffs, two of whom are attorneys; that after the signing of the agreement, the parties learned for the first time that the parcel to be sold contained about 106 acres, and that this discrepancy in acreage did not result from any fraudulent misrepresentation; that the proposed sale was a sale in gross and not on an acreage basis, and the number of acres contained in the parcel was not considered material by the defendants in fixing the purchase price. The court further found that it was understood by both parties that the agreement did not contain a complete and accurate description of the property to be conveyed; that the buyers made a personal inspection of the land before signing the agreement, which contained a provision that they had thoroughly examined the property to be conveyed, and that plaintiffs relied solely on their own judgment in making the agreement to purchase. Based upon these findings of fact, which are supported by the record, the trial court determined that there was a mutual mistake as to the terms of the agreement and that equity required rescission with a return of the down payment.

On appeal, plaintiffs contend that the contract should be reformed to abate the purchase price to reflect the actual acreage contained in the parcel, and that it be specifically enforced as reformed. In the alternative, specific performance of the contract as written, is sought by plaintiffs.

Since there is proof in the record to show that the negotiations between the parties were for the purchase of land in bulk based on a gross rather than an acreage price, credit may not be allowed for any deficiency in acreage so as to effect an abatement of the contract price.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.