District Court, S.D. New York February 21, 1975, No. 71 Civ. 4876 (Charron v. Meaux)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-1975

OPINION AND ORDER

OWEN, District Judge.

Plaintiff Mark Charron, a songwriter, has alleged, among other things, that he is owed royalties by defendants Renleigh Music, Inc. and Flomar Music Publishing Inc., publishers of his music. There are before me two motions, one addressed to each of the said defendants, seeking to strike that defendant’s answer and for an inquest on damages for willful failure to respond to a critical interrogatory in which each defendant authorized inspection of its royalty records. Plaintiff also seeks reasonable expenses, including' attorney’s fees on each motion. Since I find a clear joint pattern of conduct by both defendants1 designed to, and which in fact has resulted in a long-continuing, and so-far successful frustration of the plaintiff’s endeavor to obtain by discovery the amount of royalties due and owing, the motions are granted to the extent hereafter set forth.

The action was commenced by the plaintiff in 1971. In February 1973, plaintiff served interrogatories on both Flomar and Renleigh. Certain interrogatories asked each defendant, among other things, for a statement of royal*66ties that had been received on plaintiff’s behalf. The interrogatories were held in abeyance until October, 1973 by reason of the pendency of a motion for summary judgment which was denied. Thereafter, however, neither defendant provided answers and plaintiff made its first motion to compel answers.

In January, 1974, the parties appeared before Magistrate Hartenstine. The issues on the motion were resolved upon the Magistrate’s recommendation, to which defendants agreed, that each defendant would make its books and records on the subject of royalties available to plaintiff for examination. In the answers to interrogatories which defendants subsequently filed, this provision was expressly made by each of them. Flomar’s answer # 4 provided that an appointment should be made with “Jack Hauptman” the comptroller of co-defendant Scepter Records, Inc.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.