Connecticut Superior Court October 8, 1976, File No. 177 (Alvarado v. Giedraitis)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-10-1976
The defendant has appealed from a judgment in the plaintiff's favor for services rendered in training the defendant's colt. The appeal raises five issues: two attack the complaint; a third, the court's validation of the plaintiff's attachment; a fourth, the court's finding in the plaintiff's favor on the defendant's counterclaim; and a fifth, the court's refusal to correct a portion of the transcript. The complaint contained the common counts together with a bill of particulars. The bill of particulars in effect struck out of the common counts all of the paragraphs not applicable. Douglass v. Brandt, 99 Conn. 161, 163. The complaint, so revised, alleged that the defendant was indebted to the plaintiff for services performed for the defendant by breaking and training his colt, and it claimed the reasonable value of the services performed and expenses. That was a sufficient averment of an employment by the defendant, express or implied. Patchen v. Delohery Hat Co., 82 Conn. 592, 594. In that case the law implies a promise to pay the reasonable value of the services. Clark v. Clark, 46 Conn. 586,588. As for the defendant's claim of variance, it is immaterial that a complaint alleges *Page 759 reasonable value and the proof shows an agreed price, or vice versa. The plaintiff recovers in either case. Practice Book 150. The defendant attacks the trial court's action in denying his motion to quash the attachment of his colt and in granting the plaintiff's motion for a prejudgment remedy. That issue is moot because following the trial court's action a statutory bond was substituted for the attachment and the attachment was discharged. Reynolds v. Vroom, 130 Conn. 512, 515. The fourth count of the defendant's counterclaim alleges that the plaintiff returned to the defendant a bailed mare in a debilitated condition and that that condition was caused by the plaintiff's neglect. The court found that the mare was returned in an unhealthy condition.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit