New York Supreme Court February 11, 1976 (Porter v. Avlis Contracting Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-02-1976

Joseph A. Suozzi, J.

In this wrongful death action, the jury returned a general verdict in favor of the plaintiff as against the defendant Avlis, the general contractor, in the amount of $300,000, and in favor of Modern Mason, the only other defendant sued by the plaintiff. The action arose out of the collapse on October 6, 1971, of a metal pre-engineered one-story factory building which was then under construction for Stokvis Multition Corp., the owner. The component parts of this building had been manufactured by Varco-Pruden, Inc., and the owner had contracted with Avlis Contracting Corp. as the general contractor.

Avlis subcontracted with Modern Mason, Inc. to do all the concrete and masonry work, and with A. D. Herman Construction Co. to erect the steel structure. A. D. Herman in turn subcontracted with Modular Steel to perform this work. The deceased was an employee of Modular Steel.

The plaintiff, as administratrix of the decedent’s estate and individually, sued the defendants Avlis and Modern Mason, who cross-claimed against each other. Avlis also instituted a third-party action against A. D. Herman, who in turn impleaded Modular Steel, the architect Grammas and the manufacturer Varco-Pruden. Prior to the commencement of the trial the action of Herman had been severed as against Grammas and Varco-Pruden, but not as against Modular.

On the evidence presented, the collapse of the building was attributed to at least six causes:

1. The installation of straight bolts to anchor the structure to the cement foundation, instead of L-shaped bolts.

2. The use of couplings to extend those bolts, which were short and could not be anchored without extending them because they had been placed deeper in the concrete than required.

3. The widening of the holes in the base plates where the bolts required extension so as to receive the couplings, which were wider than the bolts for which the holes had been bored.

*2384.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.