Wisconsin Supreme Court October 4, 1977, 75-639 (Dugenske v. Dugenske)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-10-1977

CONNOR T. HANSEN, J.

The plaintiff-respondent, Frances Dugenske (hereinafter plaintiff), was granted a default judgment of divorce from the appellant-respondent, Theodore Dugenske (hereinafter defendant), in Illinois, on October 18, 1974. The judgment directed the defendant to quitclaim to the plaintiff his interest in his homestead, located in Green Lake county, Wisconsin.

On July 29, 1975, the plaintiff commenced an action in the Green Lake county court to enforce the divorce judgment. A summons and complaint were personally served upon the defendant, who turned them over to his lawyer, Charles K. Wildermuth, for the filing of an answer. Mr. Wildermuth, who was in the process of relocating his law offices, misplaced the complaint and his related files. As a result, a timely answer was not filed.

On September 23, 1975, a hearing was held on the plaintiff’s motion for a default judgment. The defendant, by other counsel, moved orally for an extension of time in which to answer. The court denied the defendant’s motion and granted a default judgment in favor of the plaintiff, allowing the defendant twenty days in which to bring a motion to vacate the judgment.

The defendant brought such a motion, seeking relief on the ground that his failure to answer was the result of excusable neglect. The motion, which was heard on October 7, 1975, was supported by an affidavit of Lawyer Wildermuth stating that he had misplaced the papers while relocating his office, and was further supported by a proposed answer alleging as an affirmative defense that the Illinois court did not have jurisdiction to dispose of Wisconsin real estate. The motion was denied by the

*67

court’s order of October 22, 1975, and the defendant appeals.

Two issues are presented:

1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.