New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division April 27, 1977 (Millbridge Apartments v. Linden)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-1977

151 N.J. Super. 168 (1977) 376 A.2d 611 MILLBRIDGE APARTMENTS, PLAINTIFF, v. FREDERICK LINDEN AND MERLE LINDEN, DEFENDANTS. Superior Court of New Jersey, District Court — Camden County. April 27, 1977. *170 Mr. Gregory Saputelli, for plaintiff (Messrs. Saputelli and Saputelli, attorneys). Mr. Michael Taylor for defendants (Messrs. Taylor, Kotlikoff and Schwartz, attorneys). WEINBERG, J.D.C. The novel issue raised by defendants in this summary dispossess action is whether repeated loud noise can constitute a breach of the implied warranty of habitability in a residential tenancy. Defendants, residents in a garden-type apartment complex, complained to the landlord on a number of occasions that their upstairs neighbors were making extremely loud noises. The level of the noise was so loud that on one occasion, defendant was unable to study. The landlord testified that on two or three occasions it had requested the upstairs residents to cease the loud noises. Defendants contend that these efforts by the landlord were unsuccessful and therefore they began in February 1977 to escrow their rent in an effort to compel the landlord to bring a summary dispossess action against the disorderly neighbors.[1] Rather than pursuing that course of action, plaintiff commenced this action against defendants to obtain possession of the premises. The court has concluded that under certain circumstances and conditions, repeated loud noise suffered by a *171 residential tenant, which could have been cured by a landlord, can be a defense to a dispossess action under the rubric of the warranty of habitability. There have been numerous statements made by the courts of this State regarding the concept of habitability. However diverse, these declarations all arise from a common source, i.e., the doctrine of constructive eviction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.