Massachusetts Appeals Court June 15, 1977 (Commonwealth v. Cobb)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1977
Hale, C.J.
The defendant was tried by a jury, found guilty and sentenced on indictments charging him with
*422
armed assault in a dwelling, assault and battery with a dangerous weapon and armed robbery. He appeals pursuant to G. L. c. 278, § § 33A-33G, claiming that the judge’s charge to the jury was erroneous in that it singled out alibi evidence for special scrutiny.
1
The testimony may be summarized as follows. At approximately 5:30 p.m. on November 11, 1975, two men forced their way into the second floor apartment of Artis and Audrey Myers in Dorchester. They threatened the Myerses and stole money and personal property from them at knifepoint. Shortly after the men left, Mr. and Mrs. Myers went to the District 3 police station, where they identified the defendant by photograph. The defendant was arrested on December 9, 1975.
The Commonwealth’s case rested solely on identifications of the defendant by Mr. and Mrs. Myers. The defendant presented an alibi to which he and one other witness testified.
The defendant alleges that the trial judge erred in giving the following charge to the jury on the subject of the alibi presented by the defendant: “The defense is one of alibi. The law in this Commonwealth is that alibis, the testimony of alibi witnesses, should be scrutinized with great care. It should be examined for possible bias, prejudice, all the circumstances that come to you, ladies and gentlemen. The reason for that should be obvious. It is because the person offers an alibi as a defense. Obviously he can’t be two places at one time. He denies any complicity in this crime because he was someplace else. And in order to substantiate that story, he produced a witness, and it is up to you to assess her testimony and see whether it is entitled to a degree of credibility which is sufficient to create a reasonable doubt in your minds.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit