District Court, W.D. Missouri December 12, 1977, 76CV554-W-4 (See v. Emhart Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-12-1977
ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR JOIN-DER OF NECESSARY PARTY
ELMO B. HUNTER, District Judge.
This cause is now before the Court on defendant Emhart Corporation’s Motion for Joinder of Pacific Indemnity Company, plaintiffs’ insurer, as a necessary party. By virtue of certain losses suffered by plaintiffs-insureds, Pacific Indemnity entered into certain loan receipt agreements with the insureds. The form utilized by the Pacific Indemnity for this purpose reads as follows:
LOAN RECEIPT
DATED: _, 19_
RECEIVED FROM Pacific Indemnity Co. the sum of - Dollars as a loan, without interest, under Policy No__, repayable only in the event and to the extent that any net recovery is made by fthe insured! . from any person, corporation, or party, for loss or damage for which this Company may be liable, occasioned to - on or about the _ day of -, 19--
THE UNDERSIGNED AGREE(S) to deliver to the insurer herewith, all documents necessary to show his interest in said property and agree(s) to present claim promptly and, if necessary, to commence, enter into, and prosecute suit against such person, corporation, or party, who may be responsible therefor, with all due diligence, in the name of the undersigned, but at the expense, direction, and control of said Pacific Indemnity Co.
In the Presence of:
Defendant Emhart argues that “[b]y virtue of the payments made to plaintiffs by Pacific Indemnity Company pursuant to its policy of insurance, said insurer is subrogated to all right, title, and interest of plaintiffs, or the corporation which they represent, in the subject matter of this action and is the real party in interest, at least to the extent of the payments made by the company pursuant to said policy of insurance, requiring its joinder as a necessary party under Rule 19 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.” The validity of this argument will now be examined.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit