Court of Appeals for the First Circuit May 18, 1977, 76-1514 (Famous Music Corp. v. Bay State Harness Horse Racing and Breeding Association, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-05-1977
MOORE, Circuit Judge.
Defendant, Bay State Harness Horse Racing and Breeding Association, Inc. (Bay State), appeals from an order granting summary judgment to plaintiffs, Famous Music Corp.,
et al.,
owners of copyrights in certain musical compositions allegedly broadcast over a public address system at Bay State’s raceway in Foxboro, Massachusetts, in violation of 17 U.S.C. § 101,
et seq.
The order has been reported at 423 F.Supp. 341 (D.Mass.1976).
The determinative facts are not in dispute. They were placed before the District Court by means of the pleadings, answers to interrogatories, depositions and affidavits. Under the circumstances, plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment was appropriate.
To entertain its patrons when they were not absorbed in watching the races, Bay State furnished music. For this purpose, it retained Music Box, Inc. which, as an independent contractor, supplied the music and to some extent the mechanical means for its broadcast.
Bay State’s president and treasurer, E. M. Loew, throughout the years was unwilling to obtain a license from the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP), of which the plaintiffs are members, and had instructed his subordinates in Bay State to instruct Music Box, Inc. not to play any ASCAP copyrighted music.
1
Despite this admonition, on August 24, 1972 and January 6, 1973 such music was played at a time when ASCAP had monitors in the field to spot and record such transgressions.
Infringement is not disputed, but as defenses Bay State claims that (1) the infringing performances were rendered by an independent contractor for which it is not responsible, and (2) that ASCAP is barred from recovering for the infringement because it neglected to advise Bay State of its “editing service” and failed to supply Bay State with a list of its copyrighted music so that Bay State or its supplier could avoid playing it.
The courts have rejected the “independent contractor” theory,
Buck v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit