Missouri Court of Appeals April 4, 1977, No. KCD 28017 (City of Independence v. DeWitt)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-04-1977

TURNAGE, Judge.

The City of Independence, a constitutional charter city, obtained a permanent injunction against Mary DeWitt prohibiting DeWitt from operating a hotel in a building she owned so long as a public nuisance was maintained therein, and so long as she had not obtained State and City licenses for the operation of a hotel. She appeals.

DeWitt contends the court improperly granted the injunction because the City had an adequate remedy to correct any deficiencies in the hotel property under its ordinances. Reversed.

The City’s petition, by which it sought and obtained both a temporary and permanent injunction, alleged the hotel operated by DeWitt is located in a building in which rubbish, trash and flammable material are allowed to accumulate; wiring is exposed and improperly installed electrical junctions exist; highly flammable plywood is loose on corridor walls and stair wells; sewer vents are broken allowing gas vapors in the hotel; no smoke detection devices exist; no ventilation in various rest rooms; combustible ceiling tile exists in the stair wells; the stair well going to the third floor has an opening which would create a draft to carry fire to the third floor; no fire rated doors exist in stair wells; existing fire escapes are inadequate; and the hotel premises generally are detrimental to the health of the occupants thereof and the public in general. The petition further alleged the conditions described therein constitute violations of the health standards of the City. The regulations of the Division of Health of the State and the fire prevention code and uniform fire code as adopted by the City.

It was further alleged the conditions listed constitute a violation of the building code of the City with respect to the plumbing and electrical conditions.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.