Court of Customs and Patent Appeals January 13, 1977, Patent Appeal No. 76-608 (In re Leslie)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-01-1977

ALMOND, Senior Judge.

This appeal is from the decision of the Patent and Trademark Office Board of Appeals (board), adhered to on reconsideration, affirming the rejection of appellant’s application 1 for a design patent on a golf club shaft. We affirm.

Background

Appellant describes his contribution to the art of golf club shaft designs as follows:

Applicant’s design * * * relates to providing a short twisted or helical section or portion intermediate the grip and head ends of the shaft and spaced therefrom which contrasts with the remainder of the shaft which is of smooth cylindrical form * * * and because of its contrast therewith imparts a distinctive appearance to the golf shaft.

The references relied on are:

Gates 1,525,730 February 10, 1925

Chittick 2,150,737 March 14, 1939

Gouick (Great Britain) 20,623 July 20, 1905

Tryon (Great Britain) 471,020 August 26, 1937

Allen (Great Britain) 483,995 April 25, 1938

The figures from the drawings of the Chittick, Tryon, and Allen references relied on by the examiner and board, as well as appellant’s Fig. 1, are reproduced below.2

[See following illustration]

*118

Gates discloses a method of making spirally grained seamless tubing.

The drawings of Chittick illustrate, inter alia, a golf club shaft having two fluted segments separated by a smooth-walled segment centrally located on the shaft, wherein the fluted segments are twisted about the axis of the shaft to give a helical appearance.

Gouick discloses a golf club handle provided with spiral or circumferential grooves and protuberances of such a depth and height that when soft leather is wrapped around the handle, the corrugations can be felt by the holder.

Tryon discloses a golf club shaft in the form of a hollow tubular metallic body having one or more zones of undulation, each consisting of a plurality of substantially transverse, parallel or helical, circumferential grooves, the zones being disposed intermediate the ends of the shaft.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.