Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit February 10, 1977, No. 72-2254 (Sincere Navigation Corp. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-02-1977

BY THE COURT:

This litigation was generated by an accident that occurred in 1968. The delay in disposing of the case was, in part, caused by the panel’s conclusion to defer its decision until the Court en banc decided Johnson v. Penrod Drilling Co., 5 Cir. 1975, 510 F.2d 234. When we remanded this case — and we were anxious to put an end to this litigation — we stated: “We retain jurisdiction and, hopefully, will finally resolve the appeal shortly after issuance of the [district] court’s remand opinion.” 529 F.2d at 755.

We asked the trial judge to determine three questions on remand. Each question arose because of a decision that intervened between the date of the final judgment in the district court1 and the date of the decision of this Court2 affirming in part and remanding the case to the district court.

I.

A. In his 1971 judgment, the trial judge awarded damages to the survivor-plaintiffs for “emotional distress”.3 In Sea-Land Services, Inc. v. Gaudet, 1974, 414 U.S. 573, 94 S.Ct. 806, 39 L.Ed.2d 9, the Supreme Court held that “loss of society” is compensable, under the general maritime law, for wrongful death; “mental anguish or grief’ is not. We asked the trial judge to determine on remand what portion of the award was for loss of society and what portion was for mental anguish or grief. Implicit in this question was the thought that the trial judge should determine the amount to be awarded for loss of society — if his award for emotional distress did not include damages for loss of society. The trial judge stated in his response to the mandate that his award of damages for emotional distress included nothing for loss of society, because at the time of his decision Gaudet had not been decided; “[a]ll of the award was for those elements of damage more aptly described as ‘mental anguish or grief’ ”. Accordingly, on remand he determined the damages suffered by each plaintiff for loss of society.

B.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.