Louisiana Court of Appeal November 8, 1978, 9528 (Becnel v. St. John the Baptist Parish Police Jury)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-11-1978

364 So.2d 1074 (1978) Walter BECNEL v. ST. JOHN THE BAPTIST PARISH POLICE JURY and its Administrative Subdivision, St. John the Baptist Parish Public Utilities. No. 9528. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit. November 8, 1978. Rehearing Denied December 15, 1978. *1075 Rudman & Howard, D. Douglas Howard, Jr., New Orleans, for plaintiff-appellee. Carville & Edrington, Richard L. Edrington, LaPlace, for defendant-appellant. Before LEMMON, STOULIG and SCHOTT, JJ. STOULIG, Judge. Plaintiff, Walter Becnel, was awarded[1] $18,650 for a fire loss he alleged was caused by the negligence of the St. John the Baptist Parish Public Utilities (Utilities) in removing a fire hydrant that had been located within 500 yards of his property and never replacing it. Defendant has appealed. Some time before August 22, 1974, the date of the fire, Utilities moved a hydrant that was 578 feet downriver on the River Road and approximately 1,328 feet from Becnel's store, located on West 23rd Street. The record does not establish where the nearest fire hydrant to plaintiff's store was located after the one at issue was removed. The testimony of Harold LeBoeuf, superintendent of Utilities, indicates the hydrants were placed at a distance of 1,000 yards apart when they were installed. It is not clear whether they were placed on private property with the Parish obtaining and recording a servitude or on public property. Requests for relocating hydrants in this area are processed casually and generally complied with, according to LeBoeuf. Utilities failed to explain whether its accommodating policy stems from the fact that it has no enforceable servitude upon which it might rely in resisting the landowner's request or whether, as a general rule, it experiences no difficulty with informal business procedures. In any event many facets of this case are open to speculation. The established facts are sparse. We know plaintiff's store burned at 1 a. m.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.