Supreme Court of Florida November 9, 1978, 52415 (Hendeles v. Sanford Auto Auction, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-11-1978

364 So.2d 467 (1978) Philip A. HENDELES, Etc., Petitioner, v. SANFORD AUTO AUCTION, INC., et al., Respondents. No. 52415. Supreme Court of Florida. November 9, 1978. *468 John M. Green, Jr. and Steven H. Gray of Green, Simmons, Green & Hightower, Ocala, for petitioner. Andrew G. Pattillo, Jr. of Pattillo, MacKay & McKeever, Ocala and Kenneth M. Beane, Casselberry, for Sanford Auto Auction, Inc.; and Randy R. Briggs and Edwin C. Cluster of Ayres, Cluster, Curry and McCall, Ocala, for Curtis Hulsey, respondents. PER CURIAM. We granted certiorari in this case for conflict with Vining v. Avis Rent-A-Car Systems, Inc., 354 So.2d 54 (Fla. 1977). The estate of Carol Hendeles Brady brought an action against respondents for wrongful death caused by an automobile accident. The complaint sought damages from parties alleged to have had ownership or possession of the offending automobile, who were also alleged to have entrusted it to the driver who caused the fatal accident. Each of the respondents as parties defendant denied ownership, possession, and entrustment as to itself. Thus the question of the unauthorized use of the car, along with the circumstances surrounding it — the key was left in the ignition — was placed in issue. It appears from the record that the trial judge's order of summary judgment for the respondents was based on his belief that the evidence showed the car to have been stolen. The district court of appeal affirmed, per curiam, without opinion. In Vining, we held that the chain of causation between the statutory violation, under Section 316.097, Florida Statutes (1975), of one in charge of an automobile who leaves it standing unattended, unlocked, with the key in the ignition, and the injury caused by the operation of the automobile by a thief, is not necessarily broken by the intervening criminal act of the driver in stealing the car. The key to proximate cause, we said, is foreseeability.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.