Louisiana Court of Appeal November 8, 1978, 9454 (Gelpi v. Burke)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-11-1978

364 So.2d 1064 (1978) Mrs. Joyce Perez GELPI v. Richard J. BURKE, Thomas P. Eustis and Gregory E. Eustis. No. 9454. Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit. November 8, 1978. Rehearing Denied December 15, 1978. *1065 W. Eric Lundin, III, Duke & Porterie, New Orleans, for plaintiff. Clarence F. Favret, Jr., Favret, Favret & Demarest, New Orleans, for defendant Richard J. Burke. Edmond H. Fitzmaurice, Jr., Provensal & Fitzmaurice, New Orleans, for defendants Thomas P. Eustis and Geoffrey E. Eustis. Before REDMANN, LEMMON and BEER, JJ. REDMANN, Judge. Plaintiff Louisiana domiciliary, the assignee of a Texas judgment for $143,795.62 owed to a Texas bank on a Texas mortgage loan, appeals from a summary judgment in Louisiana refusing further execution of the judgment. Not at issue is the unquestionable entitlement of the Texas judgment to full faith and credit, U.S.Const. art. 4 § 1, the same in Louisiana as in Texas, 28 U.S.C. § 1738. But that a judgment is entitled to *1066 full faith and credit does not prevent it from being extinguished. Payment of a foreign judgment (either in the foreign state or elsewhere) discharges the judgment in the foreign state, and upon any later attempt to execute the judgment discussion of constitutional issues of full faith and credit would be pointless. Other means of extinguishment or satisfaction effective in the state of rendition to discharge a judgment are equally effective in all states, without taking one whit from the judgment's entitlement to full faith and credit. The core question in this case is whether this perfectly good Texas judgment, absolutely entitled to recognition by Louisiana, has been extinguished in Texas.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.