Alaska Supreme Court September 15, 1978, 3705, 3706 (Alaska Airlines, Inc. v. Sweat)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1978

BOOCHEVER, Chief Justice.

This appeal and cross-appeal is before us following the superior court’s action pursuant to our remand in

Alaska Airlines, Inc. v. Sweat,

568 P.2d 916 (Alaska 1977) (hereinafter

“Sweat I”).

In the original action in this case, Milford Douglas Sweat and his wife, Diane M. Sweat, sued Alaska Airlines, Inc., (hereinafter “Alaska”) for damages for injuries sustained by Mr. Sweat in an airplane crash

*546

near Cordova, Alaska.

1

Judgment was entered against Alaska, and both sides appealed.

2

In

Sweat I,

liability of Alaska for the Sweats’ injuries was sustained, but the case was remanded on the issues of damages and attorney’s fees. The following questions are presented for our review:

1. Did the superior court exceed the scope of the mandate in

Sweat I

by including pre-trial pension contributions in its calculation of lost pension benefits?

2. Did the superior court err in admitting testimony of Walter Steige regarding draftsman health and welfare benefits and retirement contributions, in light of the hearsay rule?

3. Did the superior court err by disregarding Sweat’s future increased earnings as a draftsman in computing employer contributions to Sweat’s draftsman pension?

4. Did the superior court err in awarding attorney’s fees?

We shall discuss the points on appeal in that order.

PRE-TRIAL PENSION BENEFITS

One of the major disputes in

Sweat I

concerned the application of the principles of

Beaulieu v. Elliott,

434 P.2d 665 (Alaska 1967), to Sweat’s loss of pension benefits.

3

Sweat’s injuries forced termination of his employment as a lineman with the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (hereinafter “I.B.E.W.”), and he secured alternative employment as a draftsman with Crews, Mclnnes & Hoffman (hereinafter “C.M.&H.”).

4

The trial court looked at the amount of benefits available to Sweat under the alternative employment, subtracted that from the benefits available under the former employment and awarded the difference.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.