Idaho Supreme Court April 28, 1978, 12413 (Schvaneveldt v. Idaho State Horse Racing Commission)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-04-1978
BAKES, Justice.
The appellant Idaho State Horse Racing Commission suspended the licenses of the respondents, two horse trainers, after chemical tests detected drugs in horses they had raced at Les Bois Park in Boise. This dispute concerns the legality of the racing commission’s suspension of the licenses pursuant to its “absolute insurer rule” without a showing the the respondents were involved in the illegal medication of the horses. The Western Idaho Fair Board, the operator of Les Bois Park, is an intervenor appellant.
Respondent John Treasure, a licensed assistant trainer, entered a horse named “Please Due” in the first race at Les Bois Park on May 22, 1976. Respondent Jerry Schvaneveldt, a licensed trainer, entered a horse named “Missy Feast” in the second race at Les Bois Park on May 23, 1976. Both horses won their respective races. As required by the racing commission’s rules, a urine specimen was taken from each winning horse immediately following the race. Chemical analysis of the specimens taken from Missy Feast and Please Due revealed the presence of hydromorphone, a narcotic.
The commission held a formal hearing concerning possible violations of Rules 4.36 and 15.19 of the Idaho Horse Racing Rules and Regulations, which were promulgated by the commission. Rule 4.36 provides that the trainer is the “absolute insurer” of the condition of the horses he enters.
1
Rule 15.19 provides that the presence of medication in a post race urine sample is
prima facie
evidence that the horse sampled was illegally medicated and authorizes the stewards to penalize those who participated in the administration of the medication.
2
The
*132
respondents were not present at the hearing but appeared through counsel. Following the hearing, the commission suspended the licenses of the respondents for violations of Rules 4.36 and 15.19.
The respondents appealed to the district court for a review of the commission’s ruling.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit