Supreme Court of South Carolina November 16, 1978, 20811 (Carolina Water Service, Inc. v. South Carolina Public Service Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1978

Gregory, Justice:

Thie appeal by Carolina Water Service, Inc. [Carolina] is from the order of the lower court dismissing Carolina’s appeal from orders of the Public Service Commission of South Carolina [Commission] and awarding judgment to respondent Kingfisher Inn, Inc. [Kingfisher]. We hold the Commission failed to comply with Section 58-5-290, 1976 Code of Laws of South Carolina, and revese and remand.

Carolina owns and operates a water and sewer utility company in Garden City. In March 1974 Kingfisher contacted Carolina regarding water service for a motel to be constructed in Garden City. Carolina and Kingfisher agreed that Kingfisher would pay Carolina the sum of Thirteen Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty ($13,750.00) Dollars for the initiation of water service to the new motel.

Carolina then installed a new water main from its well to Kingfisher’s location and connected Kingfisher to the new water main. Kingfisher initially refused Carolina’s demand for payment but ultimately paid the entire Thirteen Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty ($13,750.00) Dollars under protest. Thereafter Kingfisher filed a petition with the Commission under Section 58-5-270, 1976 Code, to have the Commission determine the reasonableness of the rate charged for the initiation of water service.

On September 29, 1975 the Commission filed its Order No. 18,692 in this matter. The order provides in part as follows:

. . . [I]f it is determined by and between 'the parties, or by the courts, that it was Carolina’s intent, and Kingfisher’s agreement, to charge a “tap” fee,

1

or a “connection” fee, as

*84

that term is defined in this Order, then Carolina would be obligated to return to Kingfisher the entire advancement, save $250 representing an approved “tap fee.”

2

However, if it is found that Carolina intended and Kingfisher agreed, that the charge of $13,750.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.