Alaska Supreme Court March 10, 1978, 3315 (City of Whittier v. Whittier Fuel & Marine Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-03-1978
OPINION
BOOCHEVER, Chief Justice.
This is a civil appeal from a judgment entered against the City of Whittier for breach of contract. The following issues are presented: (1) did the superior court err in denying the City of Whittier’s motions for directed verdict, judgment notwithstanding the verdict and new trial because the damages were unforeseeable or uncertain; (2) did the superior court err in denying a new trial because the verdicts were inconsistent; (3) did the superior court err in giving certain jury instructions because the instructions implied that damages were, in fact, sustained and (4) did the superior
*219
court err in granting pre-judgment interest? We find error as to some of the damages awarded and the granting of pre-judgment interest.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
On September 13, 1973, John P. Lynch and appellant, City of Whittier (the “City,” hereinafter), entered into an agreement by which the City leased to Lynch a fuel float and access ramp located in the boat harbor at Whittier, Alaska, “for the purpose of selling petroleum products to the users of the said boat harbor.” In addition, the agreement provided that the City would lease to Lynch a fuel truck at a monthly rental of $25.00. The term of the lease of the vehicle, fuel float and ramp was five years. Lynch further agreed to pay the City $.01 rental for each gallon of fuel sold.
1
Shortly after the agreement was operative, the lease was assigned by Lynch to appellee, Whittier Fuel & Marine Corporation
2
(“Whittier Fuel,” hereinafter).
During the winter of 1973-74, Whittier Fuel delivered heating fuel to customers in Whittier, using the leased fuel truck. Lynch testified that approximately 370,000 gallons of fuel were delivered between October 1973 and May 1974.
3
Net profit for Whittier Fuel was estimated at $.07 a gallon. This testimony was uncontroverted.
On July 17,1974, an employee of the City took possession of the fuel truck leased to Whittier Fuel.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit