Supreme Court of Georgia October 17, 1978, 33983 (Browning v. Orr)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-10-1978

Per curiam.

This appeal is from the dismissal of a complaint for injunction and. other relief.

Browning sued Orr and her employers, alleging: Orr entered into a contract with Browning to solicit orders for his products. The contract provided: "In the event of cancellation, representative shall not solicit orders for products similar to or competitive with Pioneer’s products within the counties enumerated in paragraph 1 for a period of twelve months following the effective date of cancellation. Representative further agrees that for said period of twelve months he shall not personally, or as a partner, or as a member of management of another organization participate in the manufacture or distribution of products similar to or competitive with Pioneer’s products, within said counties.” Orr canceled

*381

her employment contract and has accepted employment with the other defendants to sell products in competition with those of Browning in violation of the quoted covenant.

Argued September 18, 1978

Decided October 17, 1978.

Wayne F. Browning, Jr.,

for appellants.

Donald A. Weissman, Katz, Paller & Land, James Killough,

for appellees.

The trial judge held that the contract "is overly broad and unreasonable by reason of the limitations on employment imposed by the second sentence of paragraph 11 which would prohibit defendant Orr’s employment in the 'manufacture’ of competing products in the defined area.” The complaint was dismissed for failure to state a claim.

The appellant Browning asserts that the court erred in finding that the second sentence of the covenant not to compete is overly broad and unreasonable; and that, even if unreasonable, the court should have considered the first and second sentences as separate covenants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.