Court of Appeals of North Carolina February 7, 1978, 7718DC91 (Harrison v. Herbin)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-02-1978
*261
BROCK, Chief Judge.
Plaintiff contends that the trial judge abused his discretion in denying plaintiff’s motion that attorney’s fees be taxed against defendant in this action. Plaintiff argues that, as illustrated by questions asked by the trial judge during argument on the motion, the judge by denying the motion, apparently intended to penalize plaintiff for bringing her action in district court rather than in magistrate’s court, for requesting a jury trial, for refusing to seek damages from her own insurance carrier, for refusing defendant’s offer of settlement, and as being, in general, responsible for this litigation. We find no merit in plaintiff’s arguments.
G.S. 6-21.1 authorizes the presiding judge,
in his discretion,
to allow a reasonable attorney fee for the successful party in a personal injury or property damage suit where the damage recovery is $2,000.00 or less. The rationale behind the statute was stated by our Supreme Court in
Hicks v. Albertson,
284 N.C. 236, 239, 200 S.E. 2d 40, 42 (1973).
“The obvious purpose of this statute is to provide relief for a person who has sustained injury or property damage in an amount so small that, if he must pay his attorney out of his recovery, he may well conclude that it is not economically feasible to bring suit on his claim. In such a situation the Legislature apparently concluded that the defendant, though at fault, would have an unjustly superior bargaining power in settlement negotiations.”
It remains a fact, however, as set out in the express language of the statute, that the allowance of fees is in the discretion of the presiding judge. Upon examining the record in this case, we cannot say that the judge abused his discretion in denying the award of fees. Defendant’s insurance carrier communicated an offer of settlement to plaintiff in the amount of $200.00, just $50.00 less than the ultimate damage award at trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit