District of Columbia Court of Appeals March 29, 1978, 11193 (W. W. Chambers, Inc. v. Audette)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-03-1978
FERREN, Associate Judge:
Appellees, E. A. Audette and Henry Seay, brought suit against appellant, W. W. Chambers, Inc., for a brokerage commission allegedly due for obtaining a ready, willing, and able purchaser for Chambers’ property. After a jury verdict, the trial court entered judgment in favor of the broker-appellees for $18,500. Appellant seeks to set aside the verdict essentially on the ground that the trial court erroneously instructed the jury to disregard the fact that Chambers, as owner, already had sold the property by the time that Messrs. Audette and Seay, brokers, came forward with a buyer and claimed the commission.
Under the circumstances, we affirm the judgment. This case does not concern the usual broker-seller relationship where prior sale of the property might be determinative. In any event, appellant did not give the trial court an adequate basis for instructing the jury on the legal theory advanced on appeal. Thus, perceiving no miscarriage of justice on the record here, we are obliged to leave the judgment undisturbed.
I.
By letter of July 25, 1972, W. W. Chambers, president of W. W. Chambers, Inc., which conducts a funeral business, authorized Henry Seay, a licensed real estate broker, to offer for sale the company’s real property located at 3072 M Street, N. W. More specifically, Mr. Chambers entered into a nonexclusive listing arrangement, apprising Mr. Seay that the company would “consider a contract” for $375,000. The parties thereby created the normal brokerage agreement under which the prospective buyer is to make the offer, subject to acceptance by the seller.
Almost a year later, in June, 1973, Ralph Borden, a salesman for E. A. Audette, a real estate broker associated with Mr. Seay, showed the property to Zweites Deutsches Fernsehen (ZDF), a German television corporation. On June 14, Werner Schaefer, a local operations manager for ZDF, sent a letter to Mr. Borden expressing interest in the property. Mr. Borden informed Mr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit