Supreme Court of Pennsylvania October 6, 1978, 551 (Commonwealth v. Lark)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-10-1978

*294

ORDER

Messrs. Justice O’Brien, Roberts, and Manderino would reverse the judgment of sentence and grant a new trial because of the refusal of the trial judge to charge the jury on the law of voluntary manslaughter as requested by the defendant.

Messrs. Justice Nix, and Manderino would reverse the judgment of sentence and grant a new trial believing that an effective waiver was not established so as to permit the introduction into evidence of appellant’s alleged oral statement.

Mr. Chief Justice EAGEN and Mr. Justice POMEROY would affirm the judgment of sentence for the reasons set forth in the opinions in support of affirmance in

Commonwealth v. Cain,

471 Pa. 140, 369 A.2d 1234 (1977), parts II and V of the dissenting opinion in

Commonwealth v. Hilliard,

471 Pa. 318, 370 A.2d 322 (1977), and the Opinion of the Court in

Commonwealth v. Myers,

481 Pa. 217,-, 392 A.2d 685, 687-88 (1978).

The judgment of sentence is therefore reversed and a new trial is ordered.

LARSEN, J., did not participate in the consideration or decision of this case.

OPINION IN SUPPORT OF REVERSAL

ROBERTS, Justice.

Police took an inculpatory statement from appellant Nathaniel Lark while questioning him in violation of an agreement between appellant’s counsel and police authorities. This questioning violated the agreement assuring appellant his right of counsel, U.S.Const. Amends. VI, XIV, Pa. Const, art. I, § 9, and thus the trial court improperly admitted the statement into evidence. The trial court also erred in denying appellant’s request for a jury instruction on voluntary manslaughter. Appellant is entitled to a new trial on both grounds.

*295

On September 4, 1970, appellant met with his attorney to make arrangements to turn himself in to the authorities. Appellant’s attorney made arrangements with the district attorney’s office. The district attorney’s office agreed that appellant would not be questioned in any way.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.