Superior Court of Pennsylvania October 20, 1978, 1586 (Commonwealth Ex Rel. Ermel v. Ermel)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-10-1978

SPAETH, Judge:

This is an appeal from an order denying appellant visitation of a child then 4, now 5, years old, on the basis that appellant is not the child’s father. Because we find that appellee failed to rebut the presumption of legitimacy, we reverse.

Appellant, John C. Ermel, and appellee, Romayne Ermel, were married on August 29, 1959. Rita Ann, the child in question, was born on October 17, 1972. At that time the parties were living together. Three years later, in October 1975, the parties separated; they are still married. From-the date of separation appellant has encountered difficulties in attempting to visit Rita Ann. As the result of a habeas corpus petition filed by appellant on July 26, 1976, a stipulation providing for visitation was entered into. However, when appellee did not conform to the stipulation, appellant

*221

filed a second habeas petition on November 12,1976. At the hearing on the petition appellee testified that appellant had sexually molested Rita Ann. N.T. 25. She also testified that appellant is in fact not Rita Ann’s father. N.T. 33-34. The lower court found that appellant had not molested the child, but also found that appellant is not Rita Ann’s father, and this basis denied visitation.

-1-

In

Cairgle v. American Radiator & Standard Sanitary Corp.,

366 Pa. 249, 255, 77 A.2d 439, 442 (1951), the Supreme Court stated:

The presumption of legitimacy is, however, still one of the strongest known to the law and can be overcome only by proof of facts establishing non-access or that the husband was impotent or had no sexual intercourse with his wife at any time when it was possible in the course of nature for the child to have been begotten:

Dennison v. Page,

29 Pa. 420, 422;

Dulsky v. Susquehanna Collieries Co.,

116 Pa.Super. 520, 525, 177 A. 60;

Janes's Estate,

147 Pa. 527, 530, 23 A. 892. This is the modern rule.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.