District Court, S.D. New York July 27, 1978, 78 Civ. 435 (Fairchild, Arabatzis & Smith, Inc. v. Sackheim)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-07-1978

LASKER, District Judge.

This memorandum takes up issues left open in our earlier opinion,

Fairchild, Arabatzis & Smith, Inc. v. Sackheim,

451 F.Supp. 1181 (April 28, 1978): (1) whether allegations that the individual defendants were implicated in a malign, even criminal, investigation, state a claim under federal law and (2) whether the individuals, agents of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“Commission”), are liable in damages for such a claim.

Id.,

at 1192 n. 6. These issues are now clearly framed by the agents’ motion,

1

pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, or, in the alternative, Rule 56(b), for an order dismissing the complaint insofar as it seeks monetary relief.

In support of the motion, the defendants, Michael Sackheim (“Sackheim”) and Bernard Prince (“Prince”), argue that the allegations against them are fatally conclusory; that in any event, they do not rise to the level of constitutional grievances; that if they do, damages are not available for the constitutional injuries claimed; and, finally, that even if damages were recoverable under the constitutional provisions invoked, the agents are shielded from liability by official immunity. We find that as to those allegations which do state a claim under the United States Constitution (some do not, see

infra,

at 1185-1186) the defendants are entitled to summary judgment, since they have established an immunity defense to an action for damages. Moreover, defendants’ papers demonstrate that although plaintiffs state some claims under the Constitution, they are not entitled to prevail, either for the purpose of collecting damages or for the purpose of obtaining equitable relief. In short, the unopposed affidavits of Sackheim, Prince, and Leslie Blau show that plaintiffs have failed to raise a genuine issue as to the existence of a constitutional injury and that the best case plaintiffs can prove is a claim of common law tort.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.