Supreme Judicial Court of Maine May 24, 1978 (Hildebrand v. Holyoke Mutual Fire Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-05-1978

ARCHIBALD, Justice.

The plaintiff

1

commenced this action seeking to recover damages

2

resulting from a fire which destroyed her dwelling house and its contents, both of which had been insured against fire loss by the defendant. The defendant counterclaimed alleging it was entitled to recover $15,872.72 from the plaintiff.

3

The sole issue raised by plaintiff’s appeal is whether the presiding Justice, when ordering judgment for the defendant, erred in ruling that it would be “against public policy and violative of the provisions of the insurance contract” to allow recovery by the plaintiff even “where the evidence demonstrates that she was completely innocent of any wrongdoing.”

We sustain the appeal.

The jury was entitled to find the following facts. In the fall of 1965 the plaintiff and her husband purchased a home in Portland, taking title as joint tenants. They made a down payment on the house and gave the Maine Savings Bank a real estate mortgage as security for the balance of the purchase price.

*331

In 1968 the defendant issued a fire insurance policy on the house and its contents, which named both the plaintiff and her husband as “Named Insured.” On January 15,1970, Mr. Hildebrand conveyed his interest in the realty and its contents to the plaintiff. Three months later the defendant endorsed the policy deleting the husband’s name as a “Named Insured.”

In June, 1971, the insured’s residence was destroyed by fire which had been intentionally ignited by Mr. Hildebrand. The Justice presiding characterized the plaintiff’s conduct as being “completely innocent of any wrongdoing.”

I

The policy provided in pertinent part as follows:

“This entire policy shall be void if, whether before or after a loss, the

insured

has willfully concealed or misrepresented any material fact or circumstance concerning this insurance or the subject thereof, or the interest of the insured therein, or in case of any fraud or false swearing by the insured relating thereto.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.