Court of Chancery of Delaware May 10, 1978 (Beals v. Washington International, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-05-1978

HARTNETT, Vice Chancellor.

In this action plaintiffs are former stockholders of defendant-Formac, Inc. (For-mac). They were eliminated from equity participation in Formac as a result of a merger whereby defendant-MLZ, Inc. (MLZ) was merged into Formac. Plaintiffs seek to rescind the merger alleging misstatement of fact in the Proxy Statement in connection with the merger, and that the merger was approved only because of an illegal conspiracy among certain individual defendants who have not been served in this action.

At the time of the merger MLZ was a wholly owned subsidiary of defendant-Washington International, Inc. (Washington). As a result of the merger Washington became the owner of all the stock of Formac. Plaintiffs, in their Complaint, seek both compensatory and punitive damages.

Washington and Formac moved to strike plaintiffs’ demand for punitive damages, alleging that this Court does not have jurisdiction to award them.

Formac also moved to quash the service of process on MLZ since it is claimed that MLZ was not in existence when the service of process on MLZ was made.

The two motions will be discussed separately.

THE MOTION TO STRIKE THE CLAIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES

I

This Court’s jurisdiction is primarily based on Article IV, § 10

1

of the Delaware Constitution. Article IV, § 17

2

of the Dela

*1158

ware Constitution gives the General Assembly authority to confer additional jurisdiction upon this Court but no statute has been enacted conferring upon this Court jurisdiction to impose punitive damages.

It is the law of this State that the jurisdiction vested in this Court by Del.Const. art. IV, § 10 is the same as that which was possessed by the high court of chancery in England, at the time of the separation of the colonies.

duPont v. duPont,

Del.Supr., 85 A.2d 724 (1951);

First Nat. Bank of Frankford v. Andrews,

Del.Ch., 28 A.2d 676 (1942);

Glanding

v.

Industrial Trust Co.,

Del.Supr., 45 A.2d 553 (1945);

Theisen v. Hoey,

Del.Ch., 51 A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.