Court of Special Appeals of Maryland June 12, 1978, 1164, September Term, 1977 (State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Brethren Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-06-1978

Lowe, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This case involves the interests in insurance proceeds of two disinterested parties of interest. The interested parties of interest, as well as the disinterested parties of interest, agree on whose ultimate interest must be protected, but all are interested in the source from which that interest must be satisfied. Paraphrasing Dorothy Parker, it is not always the tragedies that come to court, it is the messes as well.

On June 27, 1975, Harry E. and Barbara Anne Conrad purchased a home from William D. Perryman and Dennis R. Conner, who in turn took back a mortgage containing a covenant by the mortgagors (Conrads) to insure the property and cause the policy to be endorsed so as to protect the interests of the mortgagees (Perryman and Conner).

The stipulated facts show no insurance was obtained by anyone until

one of the mortgagees

was bound by a $30,000 fire insurance binder on January 1, 1976, issued by State Farm Fire and Casualty Company who is the appellant here.

On March 11, 1976, Brethren Mutual Insurance Co. (the appellee here) issued a $50,000 fire policy containing an apportionment clause

1

to the owners-mortgagors (Conrads). On July 24, 1976, the property was damaged by fire.

Two days later, July 26, 1976, Brethren Mutual added an endorsement to its policy adding the mortgagees as insureds

retroactively to

the policy date of issuance.

Declaratory judgment was sought by Brethren to determine whether each insuror was liable only for a portion of the loss under their respective pro rata liability clauses, and who was entitled to the proceeds.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.