Supreme Judicial Court of Maine September 6, 1978 (Toomey v. City of Portland)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-09-1978
WERNICK, Justice.
On November 22, 1972 Eugene A. Too-mey died as a result of injuries sustained on November 20, 1972 in an automobile collision. At the time of his death Toomey was employed by the City of Portland as a police officer. On October 17, 1973 Toomey’s widow, Tina E. Toomey, filed a petition with the Industrial Accident Commission
1
claiming compensation death benefits under 39 M.R.S.A. § 58. She alleged that her husband’s death resulted from a personal injury he received on November 20,1972 by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment.
After a hearing the Commission decided in favor of the claimant and awarded her compensation death benefits. From the Superior Court judgment entered pro forma on the Commission decree the employer City of Portland has appealed.
We deny the appeal.
2
1.
As a first point on appeal, the City maintains that on all the evidence an award of compensation death benefits is not legally supportable. The City’s position comprises two alternative arguments. First, the City contends that even though the employee here involved was killed as a result of the automobile collision on which the claim for compensation is based, the widow did not have the benefit of the presumption set forth in 39 M.R.S.A. § 64-A.
3
The reason for this, argues the City, is that claimant failed to make a preliminary showing of any “link” between the collision and her deceased husband’s employment with the City of Portland. Absent applicability of the presumption, it is beyond dispute, says the City, that the evidence fails to warrant an award of compensation. As its alternative contention, the City maintains that even if the presumption was in play, all of the evidence presented established as a
matter of law
that Eugene A. Toomey was outside the course of his employment when he suffered the injury which caused his death, and therefore an award of compensation is not justifiable.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit