Indiana Court of Appeals March 22, 1978, 1-577A112 (Owens v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-03-1978

*2

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

LOWDERMILK, J.

Defendant-appellant Gerald Dean Owens appeals from his conviction for theft.

1

FACTS

On August 5, 1976 Owens was sitting in the Ex-cel service station in Hendricks County reading his newspaper, while the service station manager counted his receipts. When the manager finished counting the receipts he placed them in a paper bag and put the bag into a drawer. The manager then went out to wait on customers and to repair a door, leaving Owens alone in the front room of the station. While Owens was reading his paper another service station employee came in and out of the room a couple of times.

After having been in the service station for about

1

1

k

hours, Owens took his newspaper and left. A few minutes later the manager discovered that the sack containing the service station receipts of more than $500 was missing.

The manager called the state police, who in turn contacted Owens and asked him if he would submit to a polygraph or lie detector test. Owens agreed to take the lie detector test, which was administered by Sergeant John Danberry of the Indiana State Police. Prior to taking the lie detector test Owens signed a waiver of rights form. He also signed a written stipulation wherein he and the Hendricks County prosecutor, Seth Lewis, purportedly agreed that Sergeant Danberry was a qualified polygraph examiner and that Danberry’s questions, Owens’ answers and reactions and Danberry’s opinion as to the meaning of Owens’ answers and reactions could be received into evidence on behalf of either Owens or the State. The written stipulation was signed by Owens and by Danberry but not by the prosecutor, Lewis.

The results of Owens’ polygraph examination were interpreted by Danberry to mean that Owens was lying when he said that he did not steal the money. At trial the results of the lie dectector test were admitted over Owens’ objection on the basis of the stipulation executed by Owens and the State.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.