Michigan Court of Appeals September 5, 1978, Docket 77-2981 (People v. Hanna)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-09-1978

Per Curiam.

Defendant was convicted by a jury

*519

of burning real property or its contents,

1

conspiracy to burn real property or its contents,

2

burning insured property,

3

and conspiracy to burn insured property.

4

All four convictions were related to a fire at an Inkster party store owned by defendant and his wife. Defendant was sentenced to not less than one nor more than ten years in prison on each conviction, the sentences to run concurrently. He appeals as of right.

First, defendant alleges that certain questions posed to him by the trial judge indicated to the jury that the judge doubted defendant’s credibility and, thus, prejudiced the jury against him and denied him a fair trial. Objecting for the first time on appeal, defendant refers to the following exchange:

5

"THE COURT: I have two questions. You say you were making three thousand dollars profit a month?

"THE WITNESS: Yes.

"THE COURT: What was the total cost of the business to buy it?

"THE WITNESS: The store business, I bought it for seven thousand dollars plus inventory.

"THE COURT: You could buy a business that would make thirty six thousand dollars a year for seven thousand dollars?

*520

"THE WITNESS: Well, at that time it was a guy who wanted to leave the store and sell it to me cheap.

"THE COURT: Any further questions?”

A trial judge has wide discretion in the conduct of a trial and may properly participate in the questioning of a witness. The judge may not, by doing so, prejudice the rights of the defendant.

6

One proper role of questioning by the trial judge is to clarify points and to elicit additional relevant information.

7

Where a case is being tried before a jury, however, the judge must be specially careful that his questions or comments do not indicate partiality.

8

It is not the number of questions asked by the court, but the content of the questions and their possible impact on the jury which is crucial to an appellate review.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.