Superior Court of Pennsylvania October 20, 1978, 1512 (Commonwealth v. Payton)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-10-1978

JACOBS, President Judge:

Appellant James Payton was convicted by the Honorable Alfred J. DI BONA, Jr. sitting without a jury of attempted rape and indecent assault. His post trial motions were denied and he was sentenced to a term of imprisonment of not less than two and one-half and not more than five years for attempted rape; sentence was suspended on the indecent assault conviction. The only issue raised on this appeal is whether the trial court abused its discretion in ruling that the six year old complaining witness was competent to testify. We hold that the court did not abuse its discretion and, accordingly, affirm.

“Competency is the rule and incompetency the exception. . . . The burden to show incompetency lies upon the party who asserts it. [Citations omitted.]”

Rosche v. McCoy,

397 Pa. 615, 619-20, 156 A.2d 307, 309 (1959). No two witnesses are alike. It follows, therefore, that every determination of competency must be individual and that the facts presented in other cases dealing with competency of a witness cannot be controlling in a subsequent case.

*143

Two generalizations, however, do control in all competency cases. First, the competency of a witness is a matter for the trial court to determine and that determination will not be reversed absent a clear abuse of discretion by the court.

Commonwealth v. Baker,

466 Pa. 479, 484, 353 A.2d 454, 457 (1976). Second, in order to find a witness competent

There must be (1) such capacity to communicate, including as it does both an ability to understand questions and to frame and express intelligent answers, (2) mental capacity to observe the occurrence itself and the capacity of remembering

what it is

that she is called to testify about and (3) a consciousness of the duty to speak the truth.

Rosche v. McCoy,

397 Pa. at 620-21, 156 A.2d at 310.

A review of appellant’s brief indicates that he challenges only the third criterion — whether the child had a consciousness of her duty to speak the truth.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.