Indiana Court of Appeals September 13, 1978, 2-478A114 (Parks v. SHELLER-GLOBE CORP., HARDY DIVISION)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-09-1978

Robertson, J.

Plaintiff-appellant Walter L. Parks (Parks) seeks review of an award by the Full Industrial Board (Board) which denied compensation for permanent total disability and granted recovery for temporary total disability allegedly resulting from an accident while employed by Sheller-Globe Corporation (Sheller-Globe). The only issue presented for our consideration on appeal is whether the award is contrary to law.

It is a familiar maxim that this Court will not disturb the Board’s findings “unless the evidence is undisputed and leads conclusively to a result contrary to that reached by the Board.”

Burton v. General Motors Corp.

(1977), 172 Ind.App. 263, 360 N.E.2d 36, 38. Because we believe the evidence as properly construed compels a conclusion contrary to that of the Board, we reverse.

The parties stipulated that on February 19,1974, Parks suffered a compression fracture of the L-3 vertebra in an accident arising out of and in the scope of his employment with Sheller-Globe. The Board found

*500

as fact that the injury was the catalyst in activating a pre-existing dormant condition of multiple myeloma, a form of plasma cell leukemia. The Board further found that Parks’s condition worsened, that he was unable to resume work, and that the only medical witness testified Parks was permanently and totally disabled.

Nevertheless, the Board awarded temporary total disability upon the basis that in the absence of the multiple myeloma condition, the compression fracture might have healed, and Parks could have returned to work within six months. Additionally, the Board stated that in a “normal individual” such an accident “would probably have not caused the [compression] fracture.”

The liability of an employer, however, is not limited to injuries which physically and mentally perfect employees would sustain in similar accidents; rather, he is bound to take employees as he finds them.

Goodman v. Olin Matheison Chemical Corp.

(1977), 174 Ind.App. 396, 367 N.E.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.