Michigan Court of Appeals April 18, 1978, Docket 77-2096 (Chisnell v. Chisnell)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-04-1978

D. C. Riley, J.

This case involves an issue of first impression in Michigan;

i.e.,

the treatment of military retirement pay in a divorce proceeding. The issue focuses on the question of whether the trial court erred in awarding plaintiff a one-half interest in defendant’s net retirement benefits as part of a property settlement where no provision was made for alimony.

Defendant entered the United States Army in 1949 but he left the military in 1953. He re-enlisted in 1955, just prior to his marriage to plaintiff, and retired in 1972 as Chief Warrant Officer, fourth class.

No children were born of this marriage. The parties owned two lots and accumulated personal property, including several cars, a boat, a camper and a car trailer, some of which were encumbered

*701

by loans. In 1975, the plaintiff filed her complaint for divorce.

Following a bench trial, the court awarded plaintiff a divorce providing that neither party receive alimony and that all of the marital property be sold, with the proceeds going first to settle the liens on the property and the remainder to be divided equally between the parties.

The court found that defendant, by virtue of his years of military service, was receiving military retirement pay of $9600 per year. After deducting 20 per cent of this amount for taxes, the court awarded plaintiff, as part of the property settlement, one-half of the net amount, or $320 per month. The payments were ordered to continue until the death of either party.

Defendant contends on appeal that military retirement pay is not a marital asset subject to division in a divorce action property settlement. He argues that the retirement pay is analagous to wages, which can only be considered as a factor in granting alimony. Since no alimony was awarded here, defendant argues, plaintiff has no interest in the net retirement pay.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.