Supreme Court of Iowa June 28, 1978, 60585 (Citizens State Bank of Corydon v. Central Savings Ass'n)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-06-1978

HARRIS, Justice.

This suit involves a jurisdictional question under the Iowa administrative procedure Act. Because appeal is from an order of the trial court overruling a special appearance it is interlocutory. No permission for an interlocutory appeal was sought or granted under rule 2, Rules of Appellate Procedure. Accordingly we are obliged to dismiss the appeal.

Central Savings Association of Chariton, Iowa (CSA) wished to open a branch office in Corydon, Iowa. Pursuant to § 534.3, The Code, CSA sought permission of the executive council to do so. Over the protest of three banks, including the plaintiff Citizens State Bank of Corydon, Iowa, the executive council on September 24, 1976 granted permission for the branch office.

This declaratory judgment action was filed October 15, 1976 seeking judgment declaring the action of the executive council null and void for the reason it was not based on statutory authority. CSA was not made a party to the action and received no notice of it. On January 28, 1977, CSA filed a special appearance alleging, under § 17A.19(2), The Code, it should have been timely served

1

with a copy of the petition. The special appearance pointed out the

*34

mailing, as to the parties required, is jurisdictional.

The parties dispute whether CSA was a party of record in the proceeding before the executive council and whether this action involves review of an agency action in a contested case. The special appearance was overruled. CSA brought this appeal without seeking or obtaining permission for an interlocutory appeal under rule 2, R.Ap.P.

I. In order for a trial court ruling to be final it must be decisive of the case.

Simpson v. Low-Rent Housing Agcy. of Mount Ayr,

224 N.W.2d 624, 631 (Iowa 1974) and authorities. The trial court’s ruling was not decisive of this case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.