Wisconsin Supreme Court January 3, 1978, 75-624 (Wieczorek v. City of Franklin)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-01-1978
ABRAHAMSON, J.
The sole issue on appeal is whether the property owners are entitled to attorney’s fees under sec. 32.05(5), Stats., where the condemnation proceeding is terminated as a result of a defect in the jurisdictional offer. The trial court awarded fees; we reverse, holding that the owners were not entitled to attorney’s fees under sec. 32.05 (5), Stats.
1
There is no dispute as to the facts. On February 28, 1975, the City of Franklin served a jurisdictional offer to purchase a sewer easement across the property ownéd by Victor and Stephania Wieczorek. Pursuant to sec. 32.05(5), Stats., the Wieczoreks instituted an action to contest the city’s right to condemn their property. After
*21
the Wieczoreks completed putting in their case on trial, the trial court granted judgment to the Wieczoreks on the ground that the jurisdictional offer was defective because it failed to state the proposed date of occupancy. Sec. 32.05(3) (c), Stats. Incorporated in the judgment was the trial court’s conclusion that the city could re-initiate the condemnation by sending the Wieczoreks a proper jurisdictional offer.
2
By subsequent amendment to the judgment, the trial court awarded attorney’s fees in the amount of $1,600 to the Wieczoreks under sec. 32.05(5), Stats.
3
*22
The trial court made no determination as to the other issues in the case including the question whether the city had the power to condemn the property described in the jurisdictional offer for the installation of sanitary sewer mains.
4
The appeal here involves only the award of $1,600 attorney fees as provided in the amended judgment.
The city contends that attorney’s fees were improperly awarded because the trial court did not enter a “final judgment” that the city “cannot condemn the property described in the jurisdictional offer.” The trial court, argues the city, decided only that the jurisdictional offer was procedurally defective and that a second jurisdictional offer could be served.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit