California Court of Appeal December 19, 1978, Civ. 16464 (Rodrigues v. Campbell Industries)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-12-1978

*497

Opinion

COLOGNE, J.

Plaintiffs, crew members of the purse seiner fishing vessel J/V

Lucky Strike,

appeal a judgment of dismissal after the trial court sustained the demurrer of the vessel’s manufacturers, defendants Campbell Industries and San Diego Marine, without leave to amend.

Plaintiffs’ five-count complaint against the manufacturers sought money damages for the crew members’ loss of earnings and share of the catch alleged to have been a result of the manufacturer’s participation in constructing

1

the vessel and selling it to plaintiffs’ employer CHB Foods, Inc.

2

The gist of the complaint is the vessel’s rudder and component parts were unfit, resulting in the vessel having to return from the high seas to shore for repairs, thus depriving the plaintiffs of earnings and a share of the catch during the shutdown for repair.

It is alleged as to all causes of action the plaintiffs are American merchant seamen bringing the action under the Jones Act, under general maritime law, and under all other applicable statutes.

The first and third causes of action sound in tort, alleging negligence and strict liability as bases of the manufacturers’ liability.

The second cause of action alleges the manufacturers expressly or impliedly warranted and represented the vessel was free from defects, safe, or merchantable quality and fit for its intended purpose, and plaintiffs justifiably relied on the warranty representations, but the warranties and warranty representations were untrue and breached by the manufacturers and the vessel was made unfit with the resultant loss of earnings and share of the catch.

The fourth cause of action alleges a breach of contract by the manufacturers’ failing to construct the vessel fit for its intended purpose of fishing on the high seas as agreed to in the construction contract between the manufacturers and CHB Foods.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.