District of Columbia Court of Appeals May 23, 1978, 11662 (Hsu v. Thomas)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-05-1978

PER CURIAM:

This appeal is from judgments entered in consolidated actions between the parties tried in the Landlord and Tenant Branch of Superior Court. First, appellee-tenant sued her landlord demanding that their rental agreement be set aside and the rent she had paid to the landlord be refunded to her. Appellant-landlord then brought an action against the tenant to recover unpaid rent and for possession of the leased premises based upon the same unpaid rent. Thereafter, the tenant filed a motion for partial summary judgment, seeking to establish her entitlement to a refund of the amount of rent she had paid her landlord. The trial court granted the motion, finding the rental agreement between the parties void because of the landlord’s failure to obtain the required housing licenses before leasing the property.

1

Judgment was entered for the tenant in the amount of $1350, less the reasonable rental value of the premises which was to be determined at trial. The reasonable value of the premises was later found by the trial judge to be $500. Hence, the effect of the trial court’s order below was a net judgment for the tenant in the sum of $850.

It is undisputed that the landlord had failed to obtain a certificate of occupancy or a housing license for the leased premises. Moreover, it was uncontroverted at trial that during the tenancy various defective

*589

and unsatisfactory conditions existed on the premises. What was not clear from the record was whether these conditions were in violation of the Housing Code and whether they existed at the time of the lease agreement. As a consequence, the record in this case was remanded to the trial court to make those specific findings. The court, by amended order, found (1) that fourteen separate housing code violations existed during the period of the tenancy, and (2) that eight of these were in existence at the time the premises were leased to the tenant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.