California Court of Appeal January 11, 1978, Civ. 14821 (Bodle v. Bodle)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-01-1978

Opinion

STANIFORTH, J.

Lois J. Bodle appeals from an order denying her claim to the United States Navy retirement pension being paid to her former husband, Harold Delbert Bodle. The trial court found (1) the retirement was not vested at the time of the execution of their marital settlement agreement in May 1968 and (2) did not constitute a property interest controlled by that agreement. Mrs. Bodle asserts

In re Marriage of Brown,

15 Cal.3d 838 [126 Cal.Rptr. 633, 544 P.2d 561], mandates a reversal.

The parties were married June 10, 1943. Mr. Bodle entered the military service October 19, 1944 and retired therefrom September 1, 1971, approximately three years after their interlocutory and final decrees of divorce. Seventeen years of this marriage-were congruent with Mr. Bodle’s approximate twenty years of active military service.

In connection with their divorce proceedings the parties executed a marital settlement agreement (May 1, 1968), which included the following provision: “Each of us hereby warrants to the other that neither of us is now possessed of any property of any kind or description whatsoever other than the property specifically listed in this agreement and that neither of us has made, without the knowledge and consent of the other, any gift, or transfer of community property within the period of the statute of limitations.

If it shall hereafter be determined by a Court of competent jurisdiction that either of us is now possessed of any property not

*762

set forth above

or that one of us had made, without the consent of the other, any gift or transfer of community property other than as set forth above

each of us hereby covenants and agrees to pay to the other on demand an amount equal to one-half of the fair market value of such

property.” (Italics added.)

1

The retirement pension was not mentioned in the pleadings as community property nor was it listed as an asset in the agreement. The divorce record is silent as to its existence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.