District of Columbia Court of Appeals December 19, 1978, 13312 (Griffin v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-12-1978

NEBEKER, Associate Judge:

This is an appeal from a conviction of solicitation for lewd and immoral purposes. D.C.Code 1973, § 22-2701. The- solicitation was of a covert police officer who stopped his car and was approached by appellant. Only the officer testified for the government. The defense relied in its motion for judgment of acquittal on

Kelly v. United States,

90 U.S.App.D.C. 125, 194 F.2d 150 (1952), which held that corroboration of the officer’s testimony is required. The government and the trial court were of the opinion that the rationale of

Arnold v. United States,

D.C.App., 358 A.2d 335 (1976) (en banc) abrogated the need for such corroborative evidence. We conclude that

Arnold

cannot be read to reach that result and under

M. A. P. v. Ryan,

D.C.App., 285 A.2d 310 (1971), we are required to reverse and order a judgment of acquittal, the case being controlled by

Kelly.

In

Arnold v. United States, supra,

this court abrogated the rule that a rape victim’s testimony must be corroborated. The government argues that the en banc

Arnold

holding and rationale go beyond the offense of rape and fairly may be read as overturning the need for corroboration in prosecutions for this type of solicitation. A closer reading of the opinions in

Arnold

reveals that only three other judges subscribed, without reservation, to Judge Pair’s opinion. It is that opinion which used such broad language as “in a sex case”,

id.

at 343, “rape and other sex related offenses” and “rape or its lesser included.offenses”,

id.

at 344. This author specifically reserved concurrence in “the directive to eliminate for the future the need for proof of corroboration in rape and lesser included offenses . .”

Id.

Three other judges specifically concurred in Judge Fickling’s opinion in which he withheld application of the new rule to “a related sex case” until one was before us.

Id.

at 345 n.1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.