Superior Court of Pennsylvania July 12, 1978, 650 (Commonwealth v. Thurmond)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-07-1978
combined-opinion
257 Pa. Superior Ct. 464 (1978) 390 A.2d 1330 COMMONWEALTH of Pennsylvania v. Brenda THURMOND, a/k/a Brenda Thurman, Appellant. Superior Court of Pennsylvania. Submitted September 12, 1977. Decided July 12, 1978. *465 Jeffrey G. Velander, Public Defender, Stroudsburg, for appellant. Charles P. Eyer, Assistant District Attorney, Stroudsburg, for appellee. Before WATKINS, President Judge, and JACOBS, HOFFMAN, CERCONE, PRICE, VAN der VOORT and SPAETH, JJ. SPAETH, Judge: Appellant was found guilty on two counts of gambling, 18 Pa.C.S. § 5513,[1] and was sentenced to serve three to twenty-three months imprisonment and to pay a fine of $500. On appeal she argues that the sentence was excessive. *466 It is settled that a sentencing judge must state his reasons, for the sentence he chooses. Commonwealth v. Kostka, 475 Pa. 85, 379 A.2d 884 (1977); Commonwealth v. Riggins, 474 Pa. 115, 377 A.2d 140 (1977); Commonwealth v. Wertz, 252 Pa.Super. 584, 384 A.2d 933 (1978). Here the lower court filed an opinion, in which it states: In this case, the Defendant appeared as a witness on behalf of her brother on the same criminal scene, while her brother did not take the stand. Assuming the jury verdict to be correct, the Defendant was untruthful and evasive in her testimony, both as a witness on behalf of her brother and as a witness on her own behalf. Therefore, the aspect of leniency does not enter into the picture in that no repentance is shown. At no point does the Defendant shoulder up to the responsibility, admit that she was in an illegal situation and ask the Court to aid her in rehabilitating herself. This also negatives any concept of leniency for a first offense, because that is based on the idea that a person may get into a criminal situation and not have the propensity to repeat. Lower Court Slip Opinion at 3.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit