Supreme Court of Missouri June 15, 1978, 60010 (State Ex Rel. McCloud v. Seier)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-06-1978

RENDLEN, Judge.

This original proceeding in prohibition presents the question of whether plaintiff’s treating physician may, at defendant’s behest, be named in a personal injury action to examine plaintiff who, over his objection, must submit to such examination pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 60.

In the underlying damage action, defendant moved that plaintiff be ordered examined for defendant’s purposes by Dr. Michael P. Casini, one of plaintiff’s personal treating physicians for the injuries at bar. Plaintiff, who had furnished defendant the medical and hospital records pertaining to the treatment of his injuries, objected to such selection and offered to undergo examination “by any other” physician to be suggested by defendant or the court. Rejecting this offer defendant pressed her motion and plaintiff-relator, when advised of respondent’s stated intention to order him to submit to a physical examination by Dr. Casini, petitioned here for prohibition. Our preliminary rule issued and for reasons we now discuss, the writ is made permanent.

Generally the purpose of Rule 60

1

providing for medical examinations in ac

*128

tions involving the physical condition of a party, is to eliminate uncertainty concerning the medical aspects of the cause and permit the preparation of an intelligent and informed defense. It has been stated that this procedure provides a basis for obtaining, as nearly as possible, “the exact and full truth concerning the matters in controversy, in order that [the court] may bestow on litigants equal and exact justice.” 25A C.J.S. Damages § 174(3). However, we deem it disruptive of the judicial process for the court to call upon plaintiff’s

2

treating physician to serve as the defendant’s examining physician.

Plaintiff, by bringing suit for personal injuries, placed his physical condition in issue and thus is deemed to have waived the statutory physician-patient privilege,

State ex rel. McNutt

v.

Keet,

432 S.W.2d 597 (Mo.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.