Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit March 1, 1978, 76-3086 (United States v. John C. Herring, A/K/A Scooter)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-1978

T JO FLAT, Circuit Judge:

This case comes to us on direct appeal from the appellant’s criminal conviction in the United States District Court in Macon, Georgia. The principal issue raised by the appellant concerns the district court’s course of action after the leading local newspaper had exposed the existence of death threats against a key prosecution witness. This exposure, on the last day of trial, created the potential of severely prejudicing the jury deliberations in this case. Because we are of the opinion that the trial court’s response to this publicity was insufficient to protect the appellant’s right to an impartial jury verdict and because we are unable to determine that an unbiased verdict was in fact reached, we must reverse this conviction and remand the case for further proceedings.

1

I

From the inception of this prosecution, it was clear that this case was bound to receive a great deal of publicity. The appellant, John C. “Scooter” Herring, was at one time a road manager for Gregg Allman, a prominent musician of the rock persuasion who seems to have a penchant for attracting substantial national publicity.

2

When it became known that a federal grand jury in Macon was investigating possible drug charges involving Allman, the grand jury’s investigation quite understandably attracted the attention of the news media. Media coverage intensified after Herring was indicted

3

and Allman agreed to testify at Herring’s trial in exchange for a grant of immunity. By the time the trial began, the public eye, particularly in the Macon area, was sharply focused on the case.

4

The jury selection for this trial began on June 21, 1976, in a relatively normal fashion. A venire was assembled and the voir dire examination began.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.