Court of Appeals for the First Circuit May 15, 1978, 77-1199 (Application of Montilla Records of Puerto Rico, Inc. v. The Honorable Julio Morales)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-1978

combined-opinion

575 F.2d 324 198 U.S.P.Q. 129, 1978-81 Copr.L.Dec. 25,019 Application of MONTILLA RECORDS OF PUERTO RICO, INC., Petitioner, Appellant, v. The Honorable Julio MORALES et al., Respondents, Appellees. No. 77-1199. United States Court of Appeals, First Circuit. Argued Feb. 10, 1978. Decided May 15, 1978. Irwin Klein, New York City, with whom Ricardo Rechani Acevedo, San Juan, P.R., and Steve Segal, were on brief, for petitioner, appellant. Charles E. Fitzwilliam, Asst. U. S. Atty., San Juan, P.R., with whom Julio Morales Sanchez, U. S. Atty., San Juan, P.R., was on brief, for respondents, appellees. Before COFFIN, Chief Judge, CAMPBELL and BOWNES, Circuit Judges. COFFIN, Chief Judge. 1 In November, 1976, FBI agents in Puerto Rico received information from an informant, a former employee of Montilla Records of Puerto Rico, Inc. (hereafter Montilla), that Montilla was engaged in the illegal manufacture of Motown records. The FBI investigated these allegations and concluded that Montilla was producing Motown records for which it did not possess licenses as required by copyright law. The FBI sought and received a search warrant, entered Montilla's premises on November 19, 1976, and seized a large quantity of records and recording equipment. No criminal charges have been brought against Montilla since that time. Plaintiffs sought to have their property returned under Rule 41e of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, but the district court denied their motion. Plaintiffs appeal that denial. 2 At issue in this case is the validity of the search warrant under which the FBI carried out the two day search of the Montilla factory and seized its inventory and equipment. Because we agree with plaintiffs that the warrant in question did not meet the particularity requirements of the Fourth Amendment, we reverse the district court's decision on that ground and have no need to decide the other issues presented to us.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.