Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit December 4, 1978, 77-1954, 77-1955 and 77-1992 (United States v. Cecil B. Foster, United States of America v. Alvin J. Stafford, A/K/A "Butch", United States of America v. James E. Prince)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-12-1978
Opinion for the Court filed by DANAHER, Senior Circuit Judge.
DANAHER, Senior Circuit Judge:
Defendants Stafford, Foster, Prince and Hughes had been charged with the unlawful possession of dangerous and narcotic drugs in violation of 21 U.S.C. § 841(a) and 33 D.C.Code §§ 402 and 702. All defendants entered pleas of not guilty and filed motions to suppress certain evidence obtained as incidental to or growing out of their arrest. Following a hearing on June 1, 1977, all motions were denied pursuant to a written memorandum dated June 7, 1977.
Senior District Judge Sirica in that June 7th memorandum noted that the “tangible evidence in question” had been lawfully obtained in the course of investigative efforts by the arresting officer. Subsequent developments resulted in a dismissal of all charges against defendant Hughes. The remaining parties stipulated for a bench trial, the Government proffered certain evidence not already in the record, and the parties were directed to submit post-trial memoranda, and they did so. Thereafter a Memorandum of Decision was filed on July 29, 1977, with the district judge then setting forth his ultimate findings and conclusions of law. Judge Sirica noted that the Government’s proof had not established beyond a reasonable doubt that Stafford had possessed phencyclidine “with a specific intent to distribute.”
1
However, he concluded that beyond a reasonable doubt, defendants Prince, Stafford and Foster “are each guilty as charged of one count of unlawful possession of phencyclidine.”
2
Motions for acquittal were denied.
This appeal followed.
Our inquiry accordingly will be directed to the events giving rise to the Government’s acquisition of the “tangible evidence.”
I.
Pertinent background facts may here be supplied, compendiously to be distilled from the findings reported by the trial judge. About 1:30 p. m.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit