Supreme Judicial Court of Maine September 28, 1978 (Mahler v. Tampax, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-09-1978

ARCHIBALD, Justice.

Because a review of the record convinces us that a Workers’ Compensation Commissioner based his decision dismissing Suzzann R. Mahler’s petition for compensation on a “misapprehension of undoubted facts,”1 we feel compelled to sustain her appeal from the pro forma decree of the Superior Court adopting that decision.

Beyond summarizing the procedural background, the commissioner’s entire reference to the facts and his conclusions thereon was as follows:

“It is noted that the testimony of Dr. K. Kuck, emergency physician at St. Mary’s General Hospital relates to examination performed by him on the 7th day of September, 1976, which is inconsistent with the medical testimony offered by the employee based on history relating to September 22, 1976.

This is inexplicable to this Commission and strikes at the heart of the credibility of the employee which is found not to be acceptable by this Commission.

Under these circumstances the pending Petition for Award of Compensation is dismissed.”

The petitioner had testified that on September 6, 1976, while at home, she bent over and, on arising, her back “cricked.” She received prompt medical treatment by a specialist in “Emergency Room Medicine,” and on September 14th she returned to her employment. Eight days later she slipped on a wet floor and fell, landing “[h]alf on my buttock and half on my back.”

Victor Parisién, M.D., an orthopedic specialist, began an extended course of treatment on September 28th for what he diagnosed as a “soft tissue injury to the low back and neck” caused, he opined, by “her injury of the 22nd of September.”

Dr. Parisién knew of the previous bending episode, testifying that he had seen the x-rays taken under the direction of the Emergency Room Specialist and, “I also got that from [Miss Mahler].”2 The orthopedic *356specialist had supervised a continuing course of treatment for the petitioner between September 28 and December 20, 1976, the day before the Commission hearing.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.