Supreme Court of Missouri January 9, 1978, No. 59875 (Rice v. Lucas)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-01-1978
BARDGETT, Judge.
This is an appeal from a judgment of the circuit court whereby a magistrate judge in St. Louis was ordered to afford a tenant (defendant) a jury trial in a ease brought by a landlord (plaintiff) pursuant to see. 535.-010 et seq., RSMo 1969. The circuit court declared the provision of sec. 535.040, RSMo 1969, which prescribes that a magistrate shall hear the cause without a jury to be in conflict with the civil-jury-trial provision of art. 1, sec. 22(a), Mo.Const. This court has jurisdiction of the appeal, art. 5, sec. 3, Mo.Const.
The facts are not in dispute. Blanche Rice (tenant) occupied a housing unit as a *852tenant at will under an oral month-to-month arrangement with Moro Investment Company, also known as Silverblatt Rental Company (landlord). The rent was $55 per month. On November 21, 1975, the landlord brought suit against the tenant alleging the tenant had not paid her rent from October 12, 1975, and that $110 was owed. The prayer sought judgment for the rent and restitution of the premises with costs.
The tenant filed an answer in which, after admitting a rental of the premises, she denied generally the other allegations of the landlord’s petition and then pleaded: “Defendant admits that she failed to pay the amounts of rent alleged in the Petition to have been due. Defendant [tenant] alleges, however, that said rent was not due and owing, because during the period for which rent was allegedly due, plaintiff [landlord] was in violation of the implied warranty of habitability.”1 The pleading then alleged violations of the Minimum Housing Standards Ordinance of St. Louis and asserted that the tenant had been damaged in the amount of at least $10 per day and asserted, “Because the total of said damages for the period of rent withholding exceeds the amount of rent withheld, the reasonable rent for this period is zero. Therefore, plaintiff [landlord] is entitled to no rent whatsoever.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit